Why Britain's liberal Zionists must watch NAZA

What NAZA reveals about liberal Zionism

A new documentary titled NAZA has sparked discussion among British Jewish communities, urging liberal Zionists to confront uncomfortable truths about Israel's policies. The film premiered at the San Sebastian International Film Festival in September 2026, where supporters demonstrated outside the venue calling for wider attention to its message. David Hearst submitted the piece on October 19, 2026, arguing the documentary should be essential viewing for those who identify as both Zionists and liberals.

The documentary challenges the idea that one can support Israel while maintaining liberal democratic values, showing how certain policies contradict principles of equality and justice. It presents testimonies from Palestinian citizens of Israel, highlighting systemic discrimination in housing, employment, and political representation. Hearst argues that liberal Zionists who call themselves friends of Israelmust acknowledge these realities rather than dismiss them as isolated incidents. The film does not call for ending Zionism but insists that liberalism requires honest critique when values are compromised.

How should liberal Zionists respond to uncomfortable truths

Rather than rejecting the film outright, Hearst suggests liberal Zionists use it as a starting point for internal debate and reassessment of their political stance. He notes that many British Jews already feel tension between their support for Israel and their progressive beliefs on human rights. The documentary could catalyze conversations in synagogues, community centres, and student groups about what liberal Zionism truly means in practice. Ignoring such perspectives risks alienating younger generations who prioritize social justice over unconditional allegiance.

What is the main argument of the NAZA documentary? The film argues that liberal Zionism is incompatible with Israel's current policies toward Palestinian citizens, which violate democratic principles of equality and non-discrimination.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does David Hearst believe British liberal Zionists should watch it? He believes the documentary offers a necessary challenge to complacent views, urging those who identify as both Zionists and liberals to reconcile their values with documented realities on the ground.

Does the film advocate ending support for Israel? No, the documentary does not call for ending Zionism or withdrawing support for Israel, but insists that liberal principles require critical engagement when those principles are undermined.